Showing posts with label ELECTION 2008. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ELECTION 2008. Show all posts

Sunday, June 29, 2008

I was right: Obama's influence on names

I predicted here that Obama's candidacy/presidency would prompt more black Americans to give their children traditional African names, and that this trend might extend to Americans of all ethnicities giving their children names borrowed from other cultures.

What's happening instead, already, as this NYT article reports, is that grown Obama supporters are giving themselves his middle name, Hussein, as their middle names, adopting it as a symbol of solidarity in the face of all the anti-Muslim hysteria about his background.

So far Obama's campaign has done an extremely good job of managing Obama's "brand."  Obama-sponsored memes ("Yes we can") have been extremely successful.  And a couple of (planned?) physical-gesture memes that started out looking potentially damaging (the Jay-Z brush-off, the terrorist fist jab) were swiftly picked up and championed by pop culture (no question, the fist-bump is the new high-five).

Obama's imagery is powerful.  And the reason it's so powerful is that it's impeccably, vertically unified.  The campaign's power comes from the bottom up, but its themes and aesthetic come from the top down.  People interact with that imagery in a grassroots way -- make their own posters, buttons, etc. -- but they're using as their raw material the Obama "look."  That look is incredibly well-thought-out and designed to look right, sound right, feel right -- so when it gets repeated and repeated as it trickles through culture, it all reinforces the Obama message.  

What doesn't work is for the grassroots to come up with a meme and force it upwards, because it will clash with Obama's visual and rhetorical aesthetic.  And Hussein clashes.  Although Obama's middle name is a part of his "brand" (part of his name/"brand name") whether he likes it or not, it's not been chosen as part of his brand messaging.  And so what these kids are doing becomes unintentionally subversive of what Obama's trying to do.  The main problem with their gesture isn't that it adds to the false association between Obama and Islam (because, although it does, Obama is already treading the line on offending Muslims), but that it picks apart Obama's image when what's clearly been working best for him is summing-up, generalizing, unifying.  And because it picks apart instead of generalizing, it distracts from the candidate, leading us away into a debate on religion and race between individuals instead of back toward Obama and the mass movement.

Friday, June 27, 2008

Radical Chic redux

Along with the natural/afro hair, politicized hip-hop style, and authentic African names that I think an Obama candidacy and presidency is going to bring to the forefront, I'm starting to wonder if some Black Power-influenced style is going to come back in 2009.

I mentioned in this post that I think the color black in general is going to only get more pervasive, and that in the winter the classic black turtleneck is going to be huge. I'm also imagining lots of sober, simply-cut (minimalist) black jackets, suits, and coats, and flat black boots. And I'm thinking that the camouflage trend of this winter/spring is only going to get bigger and encompass a generally militant-ish look. Plus, I continue to insist, long hair for men. Add to that a dumbing-down of (or maybe even dispensing-with?) makeup (here, here), the continuation of skinny jeans, the not-dying popularity of sunglasses, especially still the Wayfarers, the seemingly-random turban and hats-in-general trend, and it's all sounding a little familiar:
...Christ, if the Panthers don't know how to get it all together, as they say, the tight pants, the tight black turtlenecks, the leather coats, Cuban shades, Afros. But real Afros, not the ones that have been shaped and trimmed like a topiary hedge and sprayed until they have a sheen like acrylic wall-to-wall--but like funky, natural, scraggly . . . wild . . .

...The Panther women...are so lean, so lithe, as they say, with tight pants and Yoruba-style headdresses, almost like turbans, as if they'd stepped out of the pages of Vogue, although no doubt Vogue got it from them. All at once every woman in the room knows what Amanda Burden meant when she said she was now anti-fashion because "the sophistication of the baby blacks made me rethink my attitudes." God knows the Panther women don't spend thirty minutes in front of the mirror in the morning shoring up their eye holes with contact lenses, eyeliner, eye shadow, eyebrow pencil, occipital rim brush, false eyelashes, mascara, Shadow-Ban for undereye and Eterna Creme for the corners . . . (from Radical Chic & Mau-Mauing the Flak Catchers ©1970 by Tom Wolfe)

Of course Black Power overtones are exactly the last thing Barack Obama needs, so I hope this doesn't come back too strong or too soon. Hopefully not really until he's in office. And I really, really hope it'll be about black pride instead of black separatism.

Ideally it will represent, also, not the nihilistic defeated attitude of 1969, but a non-materialistic, honest attitude, and be part of a sweeping-away of the overconsumption-oriented style that has reigned for almost this entire first decade of the 21st century.

Thursday, June 12, 2008

I see the girls walk by dressed in their summer clothes

The darkness isn't going to go if you turn your head, though.  More darkness is on the way.  In fact it would be appropriate, if you see a red dress, to paint it black, because black and more black is what we're going to be seeing this summer.

That's right, here it is, my favorite time of year: time to make the New York Downtown Young Ladies' Summer Fashion Trend Report.

It's all about separates, neutrals, minimalism, utilitarianism, lots of skin, and a tough attitude.

All the outfits worn by New York Downtown Young Ladies are a variation on this theme:
  • white, black, gray, denim, or khaki short shorts or short skirt, high-waisted
  • + white, black, or gray top of some kind
  • OR black or white sundress BELTED AT THE WAIST -- NO empire line
  • potential vest, layered shirt, or jacket in white, black, or denim -- NO SWEATERS
Guidelines for accessories:
  • sandals, esp. gladiators or anything with an ankle strap, leather NOT jelly, espadrille, or other, TRUE sandal NOT FLIP-FLOP -- OR leather or canvas black/white/neutral lace-ups OR boots -- tough boots as motorcycle or winkle-picker, NOT round-toe scrunchy
  • NO bag -- OR utilitarian bag - backpack, fanny pack, or as last resort TRUE handbag (no shoulder straps and especially NO HOBOS)
  • the best accessories have some sort of significance or symbolism: for instance, political pins, wedding rings, friendship bracelets
  • earrings are long and made of feathers or fringe or are hoops or simple studs but are NOT chandelier.  multiple ear piercings are good.
  • chokers
Grooming:
  • hair: should not be styled -- it should be air-dried and left in its natural state.  If it's frizzy in its natural state, it should be frizzy; if it's flat, it should be flat.  your growing-out bangs should be in your eyes.  don't trim your hair.
  • makeup: pretty skin, some mascara.  NO EYELINER.  lip balm.
  • no nail polish
Underwear
  • I was a little wrong about bras.  it's OK to wear a bra, but it shouldn't be a heavy-duty bra.  It should be a garment and not an undergarment.  it should show -- the straps should show, or the color should show through your shirt.  or you can wear it on its own -- if it's a sports bra.  that could be really cool, actually.

The following are forbidden:
  • irony
  • color
  • notions of "luxury" or "glamour"
  • boho
Other notes:
  • the right denim is old, thrifted, men's denim -- ideally a little torn.
  • don't try to be sexy.  it's an election year, get over yourself
  • shoes are going to be getting more and more utilitarian.  sandals this summer will give way to sneakers this fall and hiking boots and flat boots this winter.  notice how the nineties are coming back?
  • also in that vein: perhaps instead of long hair, a bit of a sinead/ani moment?
  • this winter the black turtleneck will succeed these black winter clothes.


Monday, June 9, 2008

Political hip-hop style

I was waiting for something like this. I saw an amazing, amazing Obama shirt this afternoon. It was in the window of a tiny hip-hop boutique on 28th near 6th Avenue: this big black shirt with a picture of Obama (shot from below, like in all the web site photos) giving the thumbs-up, and surrounding him the giant words "YES" (above his head) and, below him, "WE CAN," in puffy gold glitter fat bold type. There were other hip-hop-style Obama shirts in the window, too, but this one was the winner.

Tons of blacks and Latinos in their teens and twenties were psyched to wear the Obama stickers I and other volunteers were handing out at the Puerto Rican Day Parade on Sunday. Lots of people passed me waving these stickers around and then would circle back and say, "Oh, Obama. Yeah, I want a sticker."

What youth culture, black culture, and entertainment culture media will the Ice Cold Obama influence infiltrate next??

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Update: Hillary Clinton's style

A friendly tipster sent me this article today, in which the writer agrees with my assessment of Clinton's wardrobe as being extremely calculated (see my post here).

Whereas I theorized that Clinton's shapeless, unstylish suits were a "middle class" costume, the writer sees them as an attempt to desexualize Clinton in the aftermath of the cleavage incident.

Either way, it's my opinion that style is yet another area in which Clinton's overly-managed persona is hurting her.  Most Americans don't think it's shallow to make a reasonable attempt to look fashionable.  A good stylist could make Clinton look professional and attractive, which would really up her political star power and help compensate for what she lacks in charisma.

Monday, March 17, 2008

It feels good to be American again

One of the little tricks of culture that I've always admired is how it facilitates group survival by making cooperation feel good.  It just seems to be something that human cultures naturally do: set up rituals through which food, money, labor, and goods are redistributed in the context of festivals full of sensual pleasure, the relaxation of societal norms, gorging on food, spectacle, dancing, and play -- in other words, fun.  Good times.

It follows that when a culture's traditions of making cooperation feel good break down, the cooperation will not work so well.  This is, of course, what we have going on in our society.  We are not all able to "party" together, exactly.  Bill Gates does not throw keggers to which we are all invited.  This is a problem.

The 1968/2008 connection has been pretty hyped recently.  So I'll add this to it: Another important similarity between the two years is that they're times when a counterculture has made important political progress that was facilitated by methods that felt good.

A friend who participated in some of the protests and marches of the late sixties was recently insisting to me that those political actions, though sometimes scary and difficult, were also pretty fun -- even "sexy."  I'm sure that point must be obvious to most people, but for me it was a bit of a revelation.  In my mind, I'd always kept the counterculture's social and political action in a separate compartment from its other manifestations (music, fashion, art, lifestyle).  I'd always thought of those latter things as mere superficial manifestations of the more substantive things that were going on.  But of course, they were a crucial element of the engine of change.  Because they provided the good times, the fun, that made taking real risks feel good.

Since the sixties, our culture has been lacking that means of making political engagement feel good.  As the medium of TV became more and more powerful, people felt more and more disengaged from, angry at, and helpless against culture. Rather than facilitating worthwhile action, popular culture became a soma.  This happened because there was no meaningful way to engage with our pop culture.  No ordinary American can participate in TV culture, because TV culture only goes one way.  All you can do with TV culture is receive it, not contribute.

But now the internet.  The internet feels good.  It's not nearly as visceral a medium of communal cooperation as actual dancing, feasting, etc. -- but it is one in which everyone can participate.  And that is the crucial part.  The internet is 2008's version of the streets and parks where the protests and happenings of 1968 took place.  It's a place where participation feels good, because it's taking place in the cultural vernacular -- a vernacular that seems pretty silly and childish to people sometimes, but there it is.  In the sixties there were folk songs; now there's Obama Girl.

Because engagement in the American political process is feeling good, American patriotism is coming back.  Michelle Obama's controversial sound bite about feeling proud of her country again is more representative of how we've been feeling as a nation than most would care to admit.  But now, I believe, a trend of popular, mainstream, non-ironic American pride is beginning, and it's showing up in pop culture.  The main examples I'm aware of so far are HBO's John Adams miniseries and the new, heavily-advertised JC Penney "American Living" line.  But I bet more are coming soon.

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Strong shoulder

When fashion editors write about the recycling of 1980s fashion, they always take care to mention that no one need worry because one thing that will never come back from the 80's is the shoulder pad.  I think this is wrong!  I think big, strong shoulders for women should come back.

Particularly when and if Hillary Clinton loses the Democratic primary, a lot of pissed-off white women are going to want to put on something that really makes them feel powerful.  So are a lot of job-seeking or job-holding-on-to women, when and if the recession gets worse.

Suits have been coming back for a long time and I think they should really come back now.  Women's fashion should stop playing around with "menswear" looks and just do some good-old, powerful, classic jackets for women.  And, underneath, perhaps a regular-old shirt instead of a fancy cami.  And on the bottom, a skirt to the knee (the conservative length for hard times).

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

The favored shade of blue for females in politics

This morning a tipster directed me to the Drudge Report's side-by-side comparison of Hillary Clinton and Margaret Thatcher wearing the same "Thatcher Blue" (link).

It reminded me of another woman in politics, Barbara Bush the elder, who also famously liked to wear bright "Barbara blue."

It makes sense for a woman seeking popularity to wear blue, since it's well-established that blue is the #1 favorite color of people everywhere.  This particular bright, primary blue is the kind of intense color that children tend to respond to well.  Maybe these ladies are trying to evoke happy childhood feelings in us?  Or maybe choosing this super-charged blue is a way of taking the conservatism and respectability of darker blue and making it eye-catching and exciting.

Monday, February 4, 2008

Generational détente

“If you want to be treated like adults, then act like adults.”

That’s a classic line teachers use to deal with misbehaving students.  It’s good advice, but often frustrating to hear and difficult to follow.  Kids do want to act like adults; they want it more than anything.  But they can’t do it so long as they’re kept in the role of children – and that’s what teachers, unwittingly, are doing to their students when they bark at them to “act like adults.”

In ancient societies, the path to adulthood was clear.  Everyone grew up in the same way, following in their parents’ footsteps and ritualistically gaining entrance into adult culture soon after puberty.  But today, because of our exceedingly complicated and everchanging culture, facilitated by sophisticated, pervasive international media, the old model is broken.

Instead of growing up into the culture of its parents, each generation of kids today grows up with its own culture.  The latest generation gets the latest culture – and because each wave of culture inevitably reacts against the previous one, the younger generation’s culture is consistently anathema to the older’s.  This isolates the young from the old, making the elders’ wisdom look obsolete and the youths’ offerings look destructive.

Kids can’t “act like adults” because they’ve become conditioned to think “adulthood” is something that belongs to a completely alien sphere ruled by a different culture.  To act “adult,” in this paradigm, would require kids to leave their culture, where they feel powerful and engaged – and welcomed – and enter the alien adult culture, which seems to have nothing to offer them but reprimands.  Of course, no kids want to do that.

And so each generation embarks on its own terrifying mission of learning, on its own, how to grow up.  I imagine that this has been going on to some degree ever since the dawn of civilization.  The problem certainly grew enormously during the twentieth century.  But only in the last few decades has the speed of change gotten so fast and the reach of media extended so far that now the young and the old seem to exist on separate planets.

I think we’re at a crucial moment in our cultural history.  In the 1960s, the Baby Boomers rejected their parents’ values and founded their own youth culture.  In the 1980s, Generation X rejected that culture and dropped out, retreating into its own anti-cultures and sub-cultures.  The Millennials are now asserting a new youth culture -- one that thrives on individual involvement in larger society through the media.

Recently, predictably, the Boomers have had a rather negative response to Millennial culture, labeling it self-centered and self-indulgent.  I think there’s a lot of truth to those accusations.  But they’re not the full story.  I think the Millennial generation would love to engage in some productive, other-centered activity – if it could only reach outside its generational bubble into the “adult” sphere.

The key to an American renaissance is wrapped up in ending the culture war, but culture is really just the medium for a deeper conflict: What we really need to do is end the generational war – and the way to do that is for young and old to together build a shared culture which everyone can enjoy and in which everyone has a stake.  We need to achieve generational détente: a reconciliation between the youngest generation (the Millennials) and its parents (the Boomers), brokered by those in between (Generation X).

I’ve seen hints of the beginnings of generational détente in the movies recently.  On one side there’s Juno and Knocked Up.  In both those movies, Millennials got into trouble by doing a very “adult” thing – getting pregnant and having a baby – when they were physically – but not psychologically, economically, or in any other way – ready.  Tellingly, in both movies, the characters’ parents, Boomer characters, ended up giving them priceless good advice and practical help that made their “adult” task work out in the end – and helped the characters to do some emotional “growing up,” as well.  In both movies, the Generation X characters – the adoptive couple in Juno and the older sister and her husband in Knocked Up – ended up in the role of commiserators with the Millennials.  They were able to offer understanding and companionship, but were short on good advice and practical help, and ended up disappointing the Millennials when they needed them the most.

In The 40 Year-Old Virgin, the opposite thing happened.  A 40-year-old man – right on the cusp between the Baby Boom and Gen-X generations – tried and finally succeeded to reach another “growing up”milestone – losing his virginity.  But just as the pregnant girls in Juno and Knocked Up were too young for their endeavors, the main character in The 40 Year-Old Virgin was too old.  He almost messed up his best chance at a good first time by relying on his Gen-X friends’ advice, which kept him motivated but ultimately lacked substance.  What saved him was some bonding with a Millennial – his girlfriend’s daughter.

The message in these movies is that the different generations need each other.   Each generation has an important role to play: The Boomers have the wisdom; the Millennials have the energy and enthusiasm; and the Gen X-ers have the communication skills.  If we can find a way to put these ingredients together, we’ll have a powerful recipe for cultural renewal.

I don’t think it’s a coincidence that the first signs of a generational truce showed up in the movies.  Like it or not, the mass media are going to become even more enmeshed into our lives in the coming years.  We need to make sure that we become empowered agents, not victims, in this new media-filled world.  And so we need to pick a leader who can navigate the media in a way that brings the generations together.  That leader is Barack Obama.

Recently our media stars have become very political, with Angelina and Brad traveling the world to do humanitarian aid, George Clooney making edgy movies, Arnold Schwarzenegger getting elected governor, and Oprah making a presidential endorsement.  What we need now is for our political stars to succeed in the media.  JFK was good at that and his skill with the media was an important ingredient in his success.  Obama is even better, and I’m convinced his media-savviness is going to win him the presidency.  He is a classic Generation X communicator: a bit detached, a bit vague, but with enormous perspective, a knack for making connections and establishing common ground, and quite visionary and inspiring on the topic of the future.

I believe all our American generations are willing to “grow up” by putting aside their cultural differences and turning the media back into a tool of positive change.  I think the Boomers are ready to cede a bit of their control of the world stage.  I think Generation X has been ready for a long time to take a bigger role in culture.  I think the Millennials are ready to look beyond themselves to something much bigger.  And I think America is ready to “grow up” as a country and participate in global government in a mature fashion.

Kids need to act like adults.  But adults need to, too.  "Adults" are people who know how to communicate in a responsible, respectful, positive way.  Obama is communicating for us right now and will successfully lead us in our efforts to communicate with each other and the world.

Vote tomorrow, Tuesday the 5th!!!

Friday, February 1, 2008

Hillary Clinton, middle-class hero?

Hillary Clinton's political cynicism is spilling over into sartorial cynicism.

I have admired Clinton's skill at putting herself together so that she looks feminine and approachable without appearing unprofessional. But after seeing her outfit at last night’s debate, it’s become clear to me that her campaign is not just trying to make her look pleasant; they are deliberately dressing her up to look middle-class.

Clinton was born, perhaps, into a middle-class family. But now, as a graduate of Wellesley and Yale Law, a former lawyer, and a senator, she is a happy member of the upper-middle class. Yet in every respect, her clothing in last night’s debate rejected the upper-middle-class aesthetic in favor of a solidly –- and, I’m pretty sure, deliberately –- middle-class look. Here’s a rundown of how her ensemble broke the rules of upper-middle-class dressing, as set forth in Paul Fussell’s Class:

Her suit: The casual and untraditional style of her jacket, which had a small collar but no lapels, sent a message similar to the one Fussell saw in Reagan’s flouting of Eastern Establishment standards of dress. By eschewing the upper-middle-class professional look, which would have her wearing very conservative, man-tailored skirt suits, Clinton distances herself from the taint of elitism. Her choice of suit color is also key. For the upper-middle-class, Fussell says, “the color toward which everything aspires is really navy.” And yet Clinton has consistently avoided navy as a neutral in favor of black and the brown of last night. Finally, the fabric of Clinton’s suit was on the cheap-looking side. On the topic of fabric, Fussell writes, "Middle-class clothes tend to err by excessive smoothness, to glitter a bit, to shine even before they're worn. Upper-middle clothes, on the other hand, lean to the soft, textured, woolly, nubby." By this measure, the jacket Clinton wore in the previous debate was upper-middle-class; the one last night was much more middle. Finally, Clinton's outfit seemed to explicitly avoid the upper-middle-class look of layering. The matching color, and perhaps even fabric, of her jacket and shell made her look un-layered and therefore less classy.

Her jewelry: According to Fussell, upper-class women wear "very little jewelry" and have "a tendency to understate." But last night, as throughout her campaign, Clinton wore more than her share of jewelry, and none of it understated: a multi-strand beaded turquoise necklace with big oval turquoise button earrings. Nothing could convince me that Clinton would pick this jewelry out for herself; it's just too tacky and ridiculous. Worn together, the pieces looked like a matching set hawked on the Home Shopping Network. Not only were the necklace and earrings oversized and inelegant, but their turquoise stones lent them a Southwestern flair which Fussell repeatedly derides as very lower-class.

Her hair: According to Class, "the classiest women wear their hair for a lifetime in exactly the style they affected in college." I wouldn't expect Clinton to hew to that standard, since in her case this would mean a too-hippieish mass of long, frizzy hair. But she doesn't even meet Fussell's relaxed guideline for upper-class hair: "a hairstyle dating back eighteen or twenty years or so." If she had just held onto one of the styles she sported during the early Clinton years, she would be set. But her hair now is ultra-updated, complete with tawdry clashing ash-blond and caramel highlights, which again make her look very middle-class.

Perhaps if men had as much leeway in their formal dress, Barack Obama's people would be fiddling around with his clothes, too; but they don't, so they're not. Clinton's camp has, I believe, made a definite choice to make her look just like the soccer moms who carried her husband to victory. I have to say I don't like it. I want my politicians to dress for serious business, not a PTA meeting. But I'm pretty sure I'm in the minority on that. Clinton's style probably has the broad appeal her campaign is going for.

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Candidates' colors part II

The Martin Luther King, Jr. Day debate in South Carolina had the Democratic presidential candidates dressing close to type. In anticipation of the more clearly-drawn battle lines of this debate, the campaigns dressed their candidates in ways that sought to visually pinpoint their unique strengths.

First, the ties. Edwards went with a bright-blue tie that looked very similar to the one he wore at the New Hampshire debate. Could it even have been the same tie? Actors going for call-backs are often advised to go ahead and wear the same outfit they wore to the initial audition, the reasoning being that this will help the casting director remember his/her first (good) impression of them. Maybe Edwards wore a similar tie to help voters remember how he looked back when he was doing relatively well in the polls.

Obama's tie was possibly another showbiz trick -- one cleverly adapted from some classic on-air no-nos. On television, certain colors and patterns don't come across well: specifically, bright red tends to "bleed," or look fuzzy, and small, high-contrast patterns, like stripes, can appear to wiggle. Nevertheless, Obama wore a red-and-white thinly-striped tie. He clearly has some good wardrobe people; they finally got him a jacket that fits, for one thing (in the previous two debates he had some collar-gap issues). They must be aware of the problems with red and stripes on T.V. I think they deliberately put him in that tie, knowing how it would look: on my screen, it glowed and scintillated, drawing attention straight to him in the wide shots of the three candidates. It was almost as though you could see straight through his chest to his burning, passionate Democrat heart. Brilliant.

Clinton's "tie" in this debate was a bright-orange scarf. Yet another bold color choice! Orange's greatest strength as a color is its power to conjure up a feeling of exuberant happiness (think of the ads and packaging for Clinique Happy). Particularly during this week of bad economic news, Clinton's people wanted to give her an aura of cheerfulness and optimism. Orange may have also been a ploy to increase Clinton's desirability: it has notoriously been used in the decor of fast food restaurants because of its proven power to stimulate the appetite. Were we supposed to feel "hungry for Hillary?" I found the effect of the tucked-in scarf to be a bit off, making Clinton seem a little too bundled-up. Still, it was much better than the distracting necklaces she wore in the previous two debates.

Grooming: Didn't the candidates look lovely? Everyone's makeup looked fantastic. Edwards's skin looked like a newborn baby's! Obama's looked like sweet milk chocolate! Clinton's makeup was much better than in Nevada. She looked a decade younger. They've switched her to shiny lipstick, which makes her mouth look fuller, younger, and more pleasant, even when she does her disapproving pursed-lips thing. Her eyeliner was better, too -- less harsh than it has been in the past. She was positively doe-eyed! Good show!

I can't write about the men's suits, because I really don't know anything about men's suits. They were...dark navy blue single-breasted suits? That's all I've got. Of course, there's much less to say about their suits, since the men's suit is such a standard garment. But there's tons to say about Clinton's suits! Her suit at this debate was very nice. I applaud her return to the nehru jacket after two debates of traditional jackets with lapels. The high, collarless neckline makes her look secure, put-together, streamlined, and modern. It's a great personal signature. I had a problem with the single button at the neckline, though: it was a neat touch, but bunched in there with the clip-on mic and the scarf, it made her neck area look cluttered. The suit was beautifully fitted to her, though. You could really see this from the back -- and weren't there a lot of shots of her from the back! I thought that was really unfair. Did we see any shots of Obama's or Edwards's behinds? Clinton's figure looked lovely, especially considering her jacket broke the cardinal rule of jackets for pear-shaped women: Thou Shalt Not Wear A Jacket That Ends At Your Widest Point. Her jacket fell right at the widest part of her rear. I understand her wanting to cover her backside, for professionalism's sake -- but at the cost of emphasizing being broad-in-the-beam? The horror! A cropped jacket that shows more leg is a necessity for elongating this type of figure! The color and fabric of the suit were the best part. The fabric looked really refined -- maybe a silk/wool blend? It had a subtle, light-absorbing texture. And the color was perfect: a flattering but serious brown: earthy, sophisticated, and just dark enough to project authority.

The poor candidates were forced to abandon the security of their podiums for a ridiculous faux-casual chair-sitting set during the second half of the debate. Each of them sat in a very distinct and characteristic way: Edwards, the populist, let his legs hang open casually, revealing a little too much crotch; Obama, cool as ice, crossed his legs; and Clinton, the proper professional lady, kept her knees together and her ankles crossed. Both men's socks were, thankfully, long enough to conceal leg skin. But only Obama's people were thoughtful enough to give him brand-new shoes with perfect, unblemished soles (not so for Edwards, whose scuffed bottoms made a couple of brief appearances).

The set was the typical red, white, and blue, in a patchwork pattern. In close-up, Edwards and Clinton were in front of blue squares on the mosaic, while Obama was in front of red. Obama's red background probably made him come off as even more aggressive during the points in the debate when he got all riled up. Clinton's scarf was not such a good match with the decor this time. She was right to pick a softer, "pumpkin" shade of orange, though, instead of primary orange to go with the set, which would have been horrendous next to her face.

At this point, with the green, pink, and now orange, it's clear that Clinton is making a point of excluding red and blue, the more obvious colors. I actually think that's a smart choice. Women so often find themselves choosing between too-masculine and too-feminine versions of business clothing. By breaking out of the box with her collar shape and colors, Clinton makes it clear that she is not trying to look like a man, but does so without looking too much "like a woman" in the wrong way. That's a truly difficult task, and she, or her handlers, are doing a great job at it.

One more debate to go... For my coverage of color in the previous two debates, see Their true colors.

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Their true colors

I've been fascinated by the color palettes of the most recent two Democratic debates. Though conservative, the set designers' and candidates' color choices were quite telling.

For one thing, they suggested that the campaigns have advance knowledge about the colors of the sets -- because there has been a striking degree of color coordination between the candidates' clothes and the backdrops behind them. (Do the debate's producers provide information to campaign officials about what colors they will be using? If so, is this done secretly or openly? I would love to know.)

At the January 5th debate in New Hampshire, the sets were large, bright screens of vibrant -- verging on jewel-toned -- red and blue. The three front-runners' color accents mixed perfectly with these sets. Obama's shiny red tie matched the glowing red of the background, and its gold stripes were a complementary safe neutral. Edwards's bright-blue tie was a near-perfect match with the clear blue of the set. Clinton, in an interesting choice, wore a green top under her black suit. The selection of green suggests an effort by Clinton's campaign to bolster her popularity with younger voters who are drawn to Obama's coolness. Green is a currently-trendy color that has associations with the trendy cause of environmentalism. It also stood out within the otherwise red-and-blue color scheme of the debate (while harmonizing with it). Green was a risky choice, since in addition to its positive connotations of tenacity and reliability, green has overtones of stubbornness, predictability, and backward thinking. But after her loss in Iowa, Clinton's handlers probably thought it was important to take such a risk in order to raise her profile. Richardson wore a blue tie, but its dark, relatively matte, subdued tone did not fit in with the rest of the color scheme -- and, surprise, he soon dropped out of the race.

I found the bright colors at the New Hampshire debate somewhat overwhelming and felt that they placed the Democrats in an atmosphere that was too aggressive and intense for their personalities. Of course, the set was designed with the Republicans (who went first) in mind as well, so it must have represented a merging of their sensibilities. Republicans need straightforward, powerful colors, which means strong primary tones; this was modified for the Democrats, perhaps, by tweaking the colors into the jewel range, which made them look more open and optimistic, referencing the party's orientation towards the future.

The color scheme of last night's Nevada debate was more nuanced, befitting its exclusively-Democratic stars. The set backdrop was composed of vertical screens displaying a close-up of the point on the American flag where the bottom-right corner of the starred blue canton meets the striped portion. That point on the flag, non-coincidentally I think, is just left-of-center: the sweet spot these candidates are aiming for. It is also a middle ground between the stars (symbolizing the heavens, or God and faith) and the stripes (symbolizing, for many people, the red of blood shed for the country and the white of the liberty it was shed for). However, the blue portion predominated, perhaps reflecting the peaceful tone the contest is struggling to maintain (in spite of the questioners' repeated attempts to rile them into a fight). Most intriguingly, the blues and reds blurred in such a way that the backdrop included whole swathes of obvious purple -- which, with its connotations of creativity, was a daring but fitting choice to underscore this primary season's embrace of change.

These set choices were made by MSNBC and its production designers, of course -- not the candidates -- so what they really reflect is the image the network wanted to project of its news coverage. That image, in turn, was chosen to reflect the mood of the audience (politically-engaged Democrats) it's trying to attract. And that mood, based on the look of the set, is very high-minded, idealistic, and positive.

The two front-running males were once again matchy-matchy with the debate's set. This time Edwards wore a tie that looked remarkably like the one Obama wore for the New Hampshire debate: an attempt to make himself look more like the youth majority's first choice? Obama's light-blue tie was the color of the blurry sections of the background at which blue (peacefulness and order) met white (freedom and purity), making a light-blue color that toned down the conservative, authoritative connotations of blue into a non-confrontational, optimistic shade -- good for someone who got flak for the "likeable enough" comment. Clinton went for pink. Pink is unabashedly feminine, and the campaign's choice of it for Clinton's top is a sign that they are, despite protestations to the contrary, continuing to play the gender card. More shockingly, pink is a color which image consultants recommend wearing in order to inspire feelings of sympathy. Dressing Clinton in pink signals an attempt to keep capitalizing on the emotional response voters had to the Edwards-Obama "double-teaming" and to Clinton's coffee-shop tearfulness. But while holding onto her emotional appeal, the Clinton campaign does not want to lose the candidate's authority: her top was a deep, strong shade of fuschia (which, unfortunately, almost-matched her lipstick in an unflattering way).

I'll watch the next debate with interest and post again on the evolving color story of the Democratic contest.

Tuesday, January 1, 2008

Back to the post-9/11 future

In Back to the Future II, while Marty McFly and Doc Brown are in the year 2015, Marty buys a sports almanac with the intention of using it to place bets once he returns to 1985. But when Doc Brown discovers what Marty has done, he scolds him and throws the almanac into the trash. The "bad guy" character Biff, who has overheard their conversation, then retrieves the almanac, steals the time machine, travels back to November 12, 1955, and gives the almanac to his younger self with instructions on how to use it to make money. As a result, when Doc and Marty return from 2015 to 1985, they find not the 1985 they left but instead a dystopian "alternate 1985" in which Biff is incredibly rich and powerful and Hill Valley is a crime-filled wasteland.

To many Americans, the present day is like the nightmarish "alternate 1985" of Back to the Future. We look at the disaster in Iraq and the related struggling American economy and damaged U.S. reputation and feel a lot like Marty did when confronted with his neighborhood transformed into a slum. We ask ourselves, "How could this happen?" The current state of affairs sometimes seems so bad that it feels existentially wrong. The comedian Patton Oswalt puts it like this:

There was this time when, in 2003, I felt like we had all fallen into this really creepy, alternate Earth--like, the "bad" Earth, where Bush won, and the towers fell, and we were going to Iraq, and Paris Hilton was successful, and everything was just wrong--everything was goddamn evil. And I felt like there was like a Earth next to ours where Gore won, and the towers still stood, and we weren't in Iraq, and Paris Hilton had been eaten by wolves, and everything was just wonderful, like...it was all good, you know?


The way we got to this point is complicated, but on one level all our trouble dates to September 11, 2001. The problems that began then were not a direct result of the terrorist attacks, which we could have prevented or at least responded to much more effectively, but the Bush administration's poorly-thought-out reaction to them. In the Back to the Future trilogy, Marty's main weakness is allowing Biff to provoke him by calling him "chicken." Marty consistently lets Biff "project" his insecurity and anger onto him, causing him to "become" his enemy and get into a vengeful, self-destructive pattern--which is just what Biff wants.

Unfortunately, this is exactly what happened to George Bush on 9/11. Tellingly, Biff is not just a good stand-in for terrorism, but for Bush as well, because, like Marty, Bush played into the hands of the terrorists by letting them successfully project their anger and vengefulness onto him. Bush then became like his enemy, allowing himself to be driven by similar religious and ideological mania and resorting to similar inhumane tactics. Like Biff, Bush let his insecurity drive him to take advantage of an unusual situation by unfairly grabbing far more power and money than he was entitled to and using it for selfish, misguided, disastrous ends.

In Back to the Future II, Marty and Doc travel back to November 12, 1955, steal the almanac back from Biff, and thereby set time back on its "proper course." My hope is that 2008 will be the year that America does the equivalent. We don't need to erase the intervening years since 9/11--and unless Barack Obama is able to ride a De Lorean back to 2001, chase Bush on a hoverboard, steal his executive power, and burn it, we can't--but we can take this opportunity to steer the course of history away from the "wrong turn" more and more Americans think it has taken and back onto its earlier path.

And while we're at it, we should follow Marty's example and learn from our mistakes. In the course of his adventures in time, Marty gains self-esteem by choosing to do the right thing. With this new self-image, he is able to abandon his old threatened, reactive course of action, which had been keeping him stuck on a dead-end course. Instead, he learns to stop, cool down, and think rationally. When he does this, he sees Biff for the essentially empty, surmountable threat that he is, and is able to deal with him accordingly. By doing the same thing, America could create not just a "good" 2008, but an even better 2015.

Let's stay away from 1885, though. Part III sucks.